A British tribunal determined that British Doctor Aloaye Foy-Yamah, who raped a young woman at his residence, would not be disqualified from practise, characterising the incident as a “one-off” offence.
Dr Aloaye Foy-Yamah, formerly a consultant at Blackpool Victoria Hospital, had his medical licence banned for 12 months due to an assault on the woman.
The police conducted an investigation but did not file charges against Dr. Foy-Yamah. However, the Medical Tribunal Practitioners Service (MPTS) determined, on the balance of probability, that he had raped the woman, a claim he refutes.
The panel, which underscored that the incident did not occur in a workplace setting, has been criticised for “victim-blaming” and inadequately evaluating Dr. Foy-Yamah’s risk, considering its determination that he had committed rape.
The campaign organisation Surviving in Scrubs, established by two physicians to illuminate issues of sexism, sexual harassment, and sexual violence within the healthcare sector, expressed to the BBC that it was “appalled” by the judgement.
“This belittles the traumatic experiences of survivors of sexual assault and undermines public trust in the profession,” co-founder Dr Becky Cox said.
“It sets a standard that perpetrators of sexual violence face minimal consequences for their actions.”
Blackpool Victoria Hospital said Dr Aloahye Foy-Yamah is no longer employed there
The General Medical Council (GMC), which regulates the register of doctors licensed to practice in the UK, had asked an independent panel run by the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service (MPTS) to permanently erase Dr Foy-Yamah’s licence.
However the panel stopped short, stating that Dr Foy-Yamah had not “abused his position of trust as a doctor” because the victim was not a patient, and noted a series of glowing testimonials from colleagues.
The legally qualified chair of the panel, Angus Macpherson, wrote: “The Tribunal considered that this was a one-off event in Dr Foy-Yamah’s personal life.
“It did not involve patient safety concerns. The Tribunal has found it will not be repeated.”
The GMC has appealed the tribunal’s decision to the High Court and said it was “deeply uncomfortable with the victim-blaming narrative from the tribunal and considered the determination lacked a proper assessment of the seriousness of the misconduct”.
Dr Foy-Yamah, who maintains his innocence, has also appealed the tribunal’s decision.
The tribunal had heard that Dr Foy-Yamah and the victim were friends.
It heard that she was lying on a sofa when the doctor began making sexual advances towards her.
The tribunal heard that she later told police: “He then goes to kiss me, I start moving my head from side to side, I cannot speak as every time I open my mouth he tries to put his tongue in my mouth.
“I am pushing on his shoulders trying to get him off. He then grabs my arms and pins them to the sofa.”
The tribunal heard the woman had said Dr Foy-Yamah then raped her.
A spokesperson for the MPTS said it did not comment on individual tribunal decisions but confirmed both the GMC and Dr Foy-Yamah had appealed to the High Court.
The GMC said no date had been listed for an appeal hearing yet.
The NHS trust running Blackpool Victoria Hospital confirmed he no longer works there.
If you or anyone you know have been affected by the people highlighted in this article, then please report those individuals to the Police on 101 (999 if an emergency) or visit their online resources for further details of the options for reporting a crime. You can also make a report at Crimestoppers should you wish to be completely anonymous. There is help available on our support links page.