Peter Tobin was identified as a paedophile serial killer only after the remains of his last victim were found concealed beneath the floorboards of a church in Glasgow.
His apprehension, while pretending to be unwell in a London hospital, initiated a nationwide investigation in the UK that lasted six decades and produced 1,400 lines of inquiry.
Operation Anagram ultimately directed detectives to a garden in Kent, where forensic archaeologists discovered the remains of two adolescents who had disappeared 16 years prior.
David Swindle, the lead investigator, is confident that the deceased Peter Tobin committed numerous further murders.
Angelika Kluk was employed as a cleaner at St. Patrick’s Church in Anderston, Glasgow, when she disappeared on 24 September 2006.
The undergraduate from Gdańsk University, who had spent the summer in Scotland to finance her language studies, was reported missing by her boyfriend.
Suspicions quickly targeted three individuals, one of them was a slender church handyman named Pat McLaughlin.
Angelika, referred to by McLaughlin as his “wee apprentice,” was assisting him in painting a shed on the day of her disappearance.
However, hours subsequent to his interrogation by law enforcement, the 60-year-old disappeared.
Shortly thereafter, McLaughlin’s photograph was disseminated to the media, and officers received a phone call that significantly altered the trajectory of the case.
A woman informed the police that the missing suspect was utilising an alias. Pat McLaughlin was a convicted sex offender, Peter Tobin, who had evaded detection for nearly a year.
While examining the chapel, an expert observed a flaw in the floor that revealed a hatch measuring 28 inches by 18 inches. It enclosed a crypt housing Angelika’s remains.
A post-mortem examination subsequently disclosed that she had been restrained, silenced, sexually assaulted, bludgeoned with a wooden object, and stabbed in the chest 16 times.
Angelika’s corpse was discovered beneath the floorboards in a room within the chapel.
The chaotic nature of the assault indicated that the perpetrator was not a novice.
Mr. Swindle informed BBC Scotland: “Upon observing her injuries, I concluded: ‘He had perpetrated this previously.’ One does not reach that age and commit murder for the first time.
The detective suspected that the perpetrator intended to relocate and inter the body.
The DNA obtained from the location matched Peter Tobin in the UK National Criminal Intelligence Database; he had been convicted of raping two 14-year-old females in Havant, Hampshire, in 1994.
Following a decade of incarceration, he returned to Renfrewshire, his place of birth and upbringing.
In October 2005, he assaulted a neighbour in Paisley but could not be located.
The church remained shuttered for a duration of five weeks.
Subsequent to Angelika’s death, Peter Tobin relocated to London, using an alias to obscure his identity.
Personal Computer Alan Murray was admitted to a hospital where a nurse identified a patient from media reports. He informed the physicians that he was pipe fitter James Kelly.
When PC Murray enquired, “Are you…” the man interjected, stating: “Peter Tobin.” You have sought my presence.
Tobin was initially apprehended for violating the conditions of the sex offenders’ register, which allowed authorities to construct a forensic case against him.
His DNA was discovered on Angelika’s body and at the crime scene. He was also connected by samples found on his watch and the T-shirt he wore in the hospital.
In March 2007, Peter Tobin was tried at the High Court in Edinburgh, where, after six weeks of testimony, the jury deliberated for little under four hours before rendering a guilty verdict.
Lord Menzies characterised his behaviour as “inhuman” and mandated a minimum incarceration period of 21 years.
Former Strathclyde Police detective David Swindle is unequivocal that Tobin had further victims.
Shortly after Peter Tobin’s apprehension, Strathclyde Police discreetly initiated Operation Anagram.
From the beginning, it had to be concealed due to concerns that any media leaks could compromise the live proceedings in the Kluk case.
Under the leadership of Detective Superintendent Swindle, the team’s objective was to document the itinerant existence of Peter Britton Tobin.
From his birth in Johnstone, Renfrewshire, on 27 August 1946, to his apprehension for Angelika’s murder, law enforcement endeavoured to trace his movements around the UK.
Mr. Swindle stated: “The premise of Anagram was fundamentally to examine Tobin as a serial killer.”
“The sole method to achieve this was to examine his life and the locations he had inhabited over the years to construct a timeline.”
Officers, researchers, and analysts undertook the meticulous work of scrutinising every aspects of his employment, vehicles, friendships, and interpersonal ties.
This was exacerbated by the fact that Tobin has as many as 60 residences and is believed to have utilised up to 40 identities.
Authorities successfully connected him to 38 mobile phone SIM cards.
The crew gradually started to construct a comprehensive depiction of Tobin’s life.
Peter Tobin was raised in Renfrew, residing with his engineer father, Daniel, mother, Marjorie, and seven siblings.
During his childhood, he was incarcerated in a borstal, and by his adolescence, he had become a petty criminal specialising in stealing and forgeries.
Tobin was married thrice, although each union disintegrated following a series of domestic abuse incidents.
Cathy Wilson, his third wife, later recounted that he was “charming and funny,” but exhibited violent behaviour after she relocated to his Brighton flat in the autumn of 1986.
She delivered their son, Daniel, in December 1987. They wed two years later; however, following their relocation to Bathgate, West Lothian, the relationship concluded.
At that time, Peter Tobin was traversing the country installing insulation panels.
The Anagram team tracked his location and juxtaposed it with unresolved homicides.
The initial coincidence was associated with one of Scotland’s most enigmatic cold cases.
The vanishing of Vicky Hamilton initiated one of Scotland’s most extensive missing persons investigations.
On 10 February 1991, Vicky Hamilton embraced her elder sister for the final time at a bus stop in Livingston, West Lothian.
The 15-year-old travelled briefly to Bathgate, where she purchased a bag of chips before proceeding to take a connecting service to her residence in Redding, Falkirk.
However, she did not arrive.
Eleven days later, Vicky’s purse was discovered in a gutter in St Andrew’s Square, Edinburgh.
Concerns arose that she had fled, although the reality was more unsettling.
A dagger was discovered concealed in the loft of the Bathgate home in 2007.
The Anagram team determined that at the time of Vicky’s disappearance, Peter Tobin was unemployed and residing alone, slightly more than a mile distant, on Robertson Avenue, Bathgate.
They notified Lothian and Borders Police, which had a cold case unit previously designated for the investigation.
On 4 June 2007, authorities conducted a search of the home and discovered a five-inch dagger-style weapon concealed in the loft space.
Traces of Vicky’s DNA were subsequently discovered, however there was no indication of her presence.
Mr. Swindle stated, “The theories regarding Peter Tobin were materialising; however, at that moment, we remained unaware of Vicky’s whereabouts.”
Lindsay Brown stated that Peter Tobin deprived her entire family of the life they might have shared with her sister, Vicky Hamilton.
The Anagram team was investigating if Tobin could have been present in the vicinity where 18-year-old Dinah McNicol disappeared.
The student was last observed on 6 August 1991, when she and her companion David Tremlett obtained a ride home from the Torpedo Town music festival in Liphook, Hampshire.
David was deposited by the driver, who possessed a Scottish accent, near junction 8 of the M25 at Reigate, Surrey.
However, Dinah, hailing from Tillingham, Essex, remained in the vehicle.
At the time, Tobin resided on Irvine Drive, Margate. He assumed the tenancy on 25 March 1991, six weeks subsequent to Vicky’s disappearance.
Investigations directed cops to former neighbour David Martin, who informed them that “Scottish Pete” was an ordinary individual who had weekend custody of his young kid.
However, one memory proved pivotal.
An overhead perspective of Peter Tobin’s previous residence located at 50 Irvine Drive, Margate
Mr. Martin subsequently informed a jury that he observed his neighbour excavating a substantial hole in his garden.
“I enquired, ‘What are you doing, Pete?'” Are you travelling to Australia? He replied, ‘No,’ stating, ‘I am excavating a sandpit for the boy’s arrival, providing him a space to play.’
“Subsequently, approximately two days elapsed, and the area was completely filled and levelled.”
The police secured a warrant and employed radar to identify irregularities, resulting in a discovery on 12 November 2007.
Mr. Swindle was preparing for a grand ball in Glasgow when he was informed by Detective Superintendent Tim Wills of Sussex Police that a body had been discovered.
“I stated: ‘That will be Dinah, then.’ While that is unfortunate, it ultimately benefits you.
He stated, “No.” It is not Dinah. It is Vicky Hamilton.
Officers immediately identified Vicky, who was reported missing 400 miles distant, by her clothing.
Evidence indicated that she had likely been subjected to a severe sexual assault and may have been strangled prior to her body being dismembered, transported across the border, and interred in Tobin’s garden.
The youngster was properly identified using dental records, while she still wore her deceased mother’s rings on her fingers.
Peter Tobin’s DNA was discovered on a plastic bag that held Vicky’s upper torso. The DNA of his son was discovered on the purse located in Edinburgh, indicating that the three-year-old had been let to play with it.
The month-long trial revealed that amitriptyline, an antidepressant with hypnotic adverse effects, was detected in Vicky’s liver.
Peter Tobin was found guilty of murder in December 2008 and received a minimum sentence of 30 years in prison.
Judge Lord Emslie described the incident as “one of the most malevolent and horrific acts that any human being could perpetrate”.
One year later, Peter Tobin was tried for the murder of Dinah at Chelmsford Crown Court.
Jurors were informed that her body was discovered, restrained and silenced, in the yard of Tobin’s previous residence in Margate.
His fingerprints were discovered on many garbage bags utilised to encase Dinah’s remains.
Residues of an antidepressant, sedatives, and cannabis were detected in her liver. Peter Tobin embezzled over £2,000 from Dinah’s building society account.
The jury rendered a guilty verdict in just 15 minutes. Judge Mr. Justice Calvert-Smith stated that Tobin should remain incarcerated indefinitely.
Were there further victims?
Notwithstanding associations with numerous unresolved crimes, Tobin has consistently refrained from cooperating with law enforcement.
Speculation has arisen regarding the vacuum, although David Swindle refrained from disclosing the names of probable victims in deference to the families.
Tobin has been implicated in relation to the Bible John murders, a sequence of homicides that instilled fear in Glasgow during the late 1960s.
However, Mr. Swindle asserted that there was no evidence to suggest that Peter Tobin was “the alleged serial killer.”
There are uncertainties regarding whether the killings of Patricia Docker, 25, Jemima McDonald, 32, and Helen Puttock, 29, were perpetrated by the same individual.
The sole forensic evidence in the instances, a semen stain on Ms. Puttock’s tights, does not correspond with Tobin’s DNA.
In 2009, law enforcement disseminated images of 32 jewellery items that were in Tobin’s possession from 1991 to 2006.
His three ex-wives had not claimed them, and law enforcement suspects they may have been retained as trophies from other unidentified victims.
In the subsequent year, specialised searches were conducted at sites associated with Tobin in Brighton and Portslade, although no evidence was discovered.
Mr. Swindle is persuaded that Peter Tobin, who spent his last years incarcerated in Edinburgh, claimed more than three lives.
“Tobin is malevolent.” He has murdered others,” he stated. “I am certain he has been committing murder since his youth.”
He stated: “The significant aspect regarding Peter Tobin is that the potential victims are individuals who are missing, and he inters bodies.”
If an individual goes missing without a relative to report their absence, how can it be determined that they are indeed absent? They simply vanish.
If you or anyone you know have been affected by the people highlighted in this article, then please report those individuals to the Police on 101 (999 if an emergency) or visit their online resources for further details of the options for reporting a crime. You can also make a report at Crimestoppers should you wish to be completely anonymous. There is help available on our support links page.